Chapter 21
Opening and closing doors on memories was getting to be a wearisome hobby for Robin. Although she and her mother had decided to set aside any search for their missing person, Robin found her resolve wavering every time she found a quiet moment to think. The worst time was the short drive home from her downtown office. She knew she could walk the distance in less time but in cold weather especially, she drove. After all, the car was warm. Usually she enjoyed the ten-minute drive. She’d listen to the news on public radio or switch to the classical music station for a few minutes of Vivaldi to help her switch out of her work mode and relax. But today, she turned the radio off. She couldn’t stop the questions in her head. So she gave in – she knew she shouldn’t – and asked the same old questions again.
At dinner the night before, Jim asked her where else she could look. Where? Where! The list was endless. Where would Eleanor go if she wanted to be in a familiar place – even if she wanted to be invisible.
Baltimore? She’d probably be in the phone book. She wasn’t. But then again, Robin wasn’t either.
Annapolis? No, someone would see her who remembered her. Everybody remembered Eleanor. Not only was she the kind of person you loved and never forgot, everybody remembered the sad story of her disappearance. Her re-appearance would create quite a stir. The Capital would cover it for a month.
Maybe she would go back to New York. She’d be invisible there. But with a child? Sure people lived in New York with their children all the time – but not a girl who grew up in quiet Annapolis.
But maybe I should think about looking there…Robin mused, and then remembered the rest of her conversation last night. I guess maybe it’s time to hire that private investigator, she thought.
Then, as she turned her car into the spot on William Street, something occurred to her that she should have thought of before. Perhaps Ellen was on the Eastern Shore – or even Delaware. It’s close but not too close and nobody knows anybody over there anymore because of all the new people moving in.
When someone disappears from your life, someone you truly loved, the grief can be crushing. Why is it at moments when you feel the loss so painfully that you see someone who reminds you of the person you lost? You can’t take your eyes off that profile, the way the hair curls, the high cheekbones or long jawline. No, of course, it’s not her. But you wish it was.
Robin felt that way again. She remembered how she’d see Ellen’s ponytail or hear her laugh in some stranger. Back then, she was mourning the devastating loss of her only sister.
But now, time had passed, but she found herself looking at strangers again, wondering how she would have changed. How she had changed. Now, she thought, when I see someone who reminds me of Ellen, maybe it is Ellen. Maybe I see her all the time.
Robin waited to get out of her car as a blonde mother walking her tall pre-adolescent daughter past her door. They were new neighbors; Robin struggled to remember their names. The child is named Caitlin, I think. The mother is...Oh, I don’t know. Jim will remind me. He knows everybody.
She glanced at her watch on the short walk to her front door. Jim had agreed to stop by for a drink at 7:30. He hoped to make it, he told her, but couldn’t be sure because of a late meeting. Robin went straight for the phone, looking for messages. Oh, no, she thought, seeing the blinking light. He’s not coming.
“Hi Robin, this is Bill,” said the answering machine before Robin could reach the phone. “I just met an artist in Easton who remembers meeting Eleanor in Vienna. She may be crazy — we didn’t go to Vienna — but I know you’re turning over every clue you find.”
Robin felt as if she’d turned to stone. The loud beep and dial tone that finished the message made her start. She remembered Jim and hurried out of her coat and gloves and put them away. Before she had finished scooping up the newspapers spread over her coffee table, the doorbell rang.
“What’s wrong?” Jim asked. She put her hand to her hair as if to straighten it. “You’re so pale. What’s wrong?”
“Weird phone call. You know. Nothing,” she answered, hoping she sounded cheerful. “I just got home and haven’t even changed. Could you fix a drink?”
“Anything for you, hon,” he said and disappeared into the kitchen. The sounds from the kitchen comforted her. They reminded her how her own house, and this house when her grandmother lived here, sounded once upon a time.
She ran upstairs to slip into a pair of jeans and old docksiders. And then she unwrapped a heather grey sweater from her trip to England. After taking another look at her face — yes she was a little pale, she thought — and sweeping blush across her cheeks, she headed back to the kitchen.
She wanted to focus on the charming scene in front of her. A gorgeous man in her house was making martinis. Dressed in black jeans and a deep red turtleneck, he looked so comfortable here in her house. He’d lit candles n the living room and turned on her favorite Deanna Bogart ballads on the CD player. She’d dreamed about an evening like this and it looked better in real life. But the phone call with Bill had left her breathless.
“Want to talk about it now?” Jim stopped measuring the gin and turned to look at Robin.
“It was so odd, really. A coincidence,” she said, and looked into the pantry for something to snack on. “I should have stopped at Cross Street. There’s not much here,”
“Sweetie,” Jim said, wrapping his arms around her. “It’s okay. Tell me what was odd.”
“Remember Bill? There was just a strange message on my answering machine. Somebody remembered Eleanor and was talking to Bill about it. He thought I’d like to know.”
Robin kept on looking in her pantry so Jim handed her a box of crackers from the top shelf. “I brought cheese,” he whispered.
“So your sister’s old boyfriend gets a call from some stranger who knew Eleanor. Now how is that possible?” Jim asked, stirring a drop of vermouth into the shaker. “Out of the blue, someone talks to Bill about Eleanor? Really.”
“I know, I know. It was so odd,” Robin said, spreading crackers on a plate. “A coincidence really.”
Bill really hadn’t said much, she thought. He had a group of artists in his office planning a spring exhibit of Eastern Shore works at the university. One woman had arrived early and while they were making small talk, she noticed a photo from the Europe trip. Bill told her about the group and she pointed to the girl with the blond ponytail wearing a Salisbury University sweatshirt.
“She said she had met her, Robin,” Bill had said. “She remembered the sweatshirt and then remembered seeing her in Vienna. She said she had been surprised to see the name of a college from the Eastern Shore and had gone up to the girl and shown her her own t-shirt from Washington College. They had laughed about the small-world-ness of two Eastern Shore college students being in the same train station.
“What I don’t understand is how she remembers it being in Vienna,” he said.
“Bill, it’s been years. Maybe she remembers the wrong train station. Or maybe she remembers another girl,” Robin offered.
“Yeah, she didn’t remember the girl’s name and said they may never have even introduced themselves.”
“What is her name?”
“Debbie something...I’ve got to have it written down in my meeting notes. Mmmm. Yes, here it is. Debbie Bunting Caine. She works in Easton at the Academy of the Arts.”
“I’ll give her a call,” Robin said. “See if she might remember something else. Maybe we can figure out if Eleanor went to Vienna after she left Salzburg.”
Robin took a martini from Jim and kissed him. “Let’s talk about it another time. So how was your day, dear?”
“Great,” he said, and led her to the worn couch. A sip of a strong drink and the attentions of her charming neighbor took her mind off the strange conversation she’d had with Eleanor’s old boyfriend.
There would be time to ponder that later, she thought. With only the slightest hesitation, she slid her arm around Jim’s shoulders and leaned toward him. Jim turned to kiss her.
Chapter 22
“Would you like to go to that Medieval Times show sometime?” Jane pointed to the faux castle that anchored one end of the mall.
Robin glanced up before sliding into the prime parking spot right by the entrance. “I hear it’s fun,” she shrugged, “but it seems a little silly to me.”
“You’re probably right. I’d much rather spend a couple of hours trying on shoes.”
“Sister, you came to the right place. They’ve got plenty of shoes in here.”
The pair headed inside. Jane was looking for sandals for a spring trip to meet her boyfriend Parker’s family in New Orleans.
“If we don’t find something in here...” Jane said, scanning the long rows of shoes.
Robin had already veered off to look at a pair of shiny red stilettos. “Hey, wait for me,” Jane said.
Without another word, the two women gathered pairs of shoes from the shelves. When they had all they could carry, they found a bench and sat down. Robin admired the brown leather and bead sandals Jane had found. Jane turned her nose up at Robin’s red stilettos. “Not your style,” she said, shaking her head.
“Well, they could become my style,” Robin protested.
She returned the shoes to the box and slid on a pair of navy sling-backs.
“Much better,” Jane nodded in approval. “So what’s on your mind?”
“Me? Oh nothing. Just shoes,” Robin replied.
“Shoes? Hardly. You wear the same black pumps every day. Or those flats, yes, the ones you have on now. Spill it. I can tell you’re nearly bursting with another clue.”
“I don’t want to bore you with yet another useless tidbit of information.”
“The sidekick needs to know everything, remember? What’s happened now?”
“Remember that woman who stopped to talk to us in Easton a few weeks back?”
Jane nodded. “When you got the birth certificate for the child in the accident, yes.”
“Bill called me to say he had met her, too,” Robin said.
“Lady really gets around doesn’t she?” Jane answered.
“She said she had met Ellen.” Robin told her friend about the meeting she had related to Bill. “When he told me about it, I didn’t remember her or our strange meeting in Easton. I even told Jim about it and the name didn’t ring a bell.”
“What was her name? I don’t remember it either,” Jane said, looking at the black espadrilles on her feet.
“Those look good,” Robin said. “Debbie Caine. Why would you remember it? She was that crazy lady who watched us through lunch. Then she asked if we had kids at her kids’ high school. Us.”
“Oh yes, her. How could I forget?”
“I remembered it in the middle of the night. Woke up and remembered her. I must have had a dream about the day. I don’t know.”
“So what are you going to do?”
“About that woman?”
“No, the shoes. I like these. They’ll work for my trip to New Orleans.”
“Oh, yeah. Good choice. I’m getting the pumps,” she sighed.
“Go ahead, get the red ones if you can walk in them.”
“I can learn. Jim might like them.”
“Right you can just lean on him as you wobble down Charles Street. And that woman? Are you going to call her?”
“I don’t know. I guess I should. I just thought she was creepy.”
“Stalker. She had stalker written all over her.”
“Poor woman. Probably thought she was helping and we’ve dragged her reputation through the mud.”
“Serves her right.”
“You know, Rob, maybe it is time to call a private investigator. Have you done that yet?”
“Not yet. How do you find one of those guys.”
“Beats me but maybe you could get someone else to deal with this Debbie person.”
“Sounds like a plan. An expensive plan but a plan.”
“Call your mother. She hired one in London easily enough.”
“Good idea. Let’s eat.”
“Robin, I’m serious. You’ll do it?”
“Promise. Cross my heart. Don’t know where or how to find someone trustworthy but I’ll give it my best shot. Now can we go have lunch?”
Chapter 23
Robin wasn’t so sure it was a good idea to hire a private investigator once she met George Foster and saw his office. And she certainly wondered why she hadn’t taken up Jane’s offer to accompany her.
Foster’s office was on the second floor of a boat repair shop down a decrepit section of Furnace Branch Road. She’d almost missed the dingy two story once-white cinder block building. A parking lot filled with old — maybe abandoned — fishing boats had caught her eye so she stopped. Yes, there it was: a flight of worn wooden stairs up to a second floor office. She parked and locked her car, held tight to her handbag and ventured nervously up those stairs. A cracked black plastic sign announced she had made it, “George M. Foster, Private Investigator, LLC.”
Unsure whether to knock or go in, she turned the door knob. What the heck, she thought and took a deep breath.
“Mr. Foster?” she called, as she stepped inside the office. It was only one room, cramped with the unmistakable smell of oil. The walls were unfinished, the floor a gray speckled tile. An ancient grey metal desk seemed to stand sentry at the doorway. It was covered in old calendars from the boat shop below. A long row of file cabinets, all different shades of tan, stretched to the window at the end of the room. A single light bulb with a string hanging from it lit the dusty, disordered mess.
“Back here,” a voice called out and a door she hadn’t seen before opened. “Sorry about the mess,” he said as he advanced, guessing her thoughts. “The landlord stores stuff up here. My office is in back.”
Foster led Robin to a brightly-lit dark-paneled office in back. A massive carved desk dominated the room and two pink-upholstered chairs stood ready to welcome guests. Foster motioned to Robin to have a seat in one of them while he took the other. She glanced around the room. Sheer curtains hung from both windows and a grandfather clock stood between then. Not a paper was in sight. A deep burgundy patterned carpet lay below her feet.
“My wife decorated the place. I mean my ex-wife,” he said.
“It’s nice,” she said.
“Clients get real worried when they see the outside and then they walk in the door and I’m always afraid they’ll run right back out again. I can’t get Bob, that’s the landlord, to clean up in front. It hasn’t ruined my business yet, but it hasn’t done it any good.”
“How can I help you? You said on the phone you’re looking for someone?”
Robin told Foster the story of how her sister disappeared and all the clues she had gotten in recent weeks that Ellen is still alive. As she talked she looked the detective over, trying to judge whether she liked him. He was a short, wiry man with wavy brown hair combed off his forehead and back to the collar of his weathered dark blue polo shirt. Deeply tanned, his face was crinkled and spotted as if he had always spent long hours in the sun. His eyes were deep-set and light blue almost grey and he watched her intently as she talked. He had glasses hanging around his neck, which she never saw him use.
He folded his hands and leaned forward. “Seems like I should be able to find her then. I’ll need a few things. Mostly numbers: social security number, driver’s license number, passport. What’s her date of birth? How about a picture?”
“Here’s her graduation picture. I haven’t got any of those numbers. Well. I know her date of birth. She was born July 20, 1970.”
“That could make it more difficult...Where was she born?”
“Baltimore City, at Mercy Hospital.”
“Anybody else that may have this information?”
“I asked my mother — she’s the only other person who would have it — and she said she hasn’t been able to find her social security number. She didn’t keep the other numbers. All she has is her birth certificate and some old report cards. And a letter congratulating her on a scholarship.”
“No, don’t need those. Well, I can look around. See what I can turn up.”
“I’ll give you a call in, say, a week. If I think it’s do-able, we’ll talk about my fees then. Let me walk you out.”
Robin called her mother to report on the meeting as soon as she got home. “I guess he’s okay,” she said, explaining the horrible building where Foster’s office was located.
“He seemed like he could help us?”
“I guess. He wanted Ellen’s social security number and driver’s license. But he didn’t seem to care when we didn’t have them. I guess he knows how to track that stuff down,” Robin said though she wasn’t convinced.
“I’ll keep going through the old boxes in the attic. Maybe they’ll turn up. But I suspect I threw them away. They didn’t seem important then,” Diane said.
“He said he’d call next week,” Robin added.
But he didn’t call. So Robin called him.
“Sorry, haven’t been able to get to your case. There’s this divorce case, you see... I’ll have more time next week. I’ll get back to you. Promise,” he said.
